16 South Drive in Manhasset (Zillow)
Across Long Island’s prestigious North Shore, three homes recently sold, offering a range of living experiences, from sprawling estates to charming historic properties. Despite their varying sizes and locations, the homes share a common theme: they embody a blend of classic elegance with modern amenities, making them desirable options for discerning buyers. The homes, located in Manhasset, Mill Neck and Port Washington, showcase the region’s sought-after blend of luxury, privacy and convenience.
The first property, at 16 South Drive in Manhasset, stands as a newly renovated colonial masterpiece within the highly coveted Village of Plandome. This home, which closed on Jan. 10, for $3.93 million, spans 4,750 square feet. Completely revamped in 2024, the house features five bedrooms and six bathrooms, alongside a spacious, contemporary kitchen complete with Poggenpohl cabinetry and Miele appliances. The meticulous millwork throughout and spa-like primary bath reflect the home’s sophisticated, upscale design. Notable amenities include radiant floor heating in the master bath, a butler’s pantry and a newly installed laundry room. The outdoor space, set on a half-acre lot, offers a lush retreat with a bluestone patio and fresh landscaping. The property also comes with access to Plandome Field and Marine, providing additional exclusivity.
Listed by and bought with Kristin E. Purcell of Compass Greater NY
Over in Mill Neck, 28 Frost Mill Road was sold for $1.64 million on Jan. 13, marking a successful transaction for this spacious colonial nestled on five private acres. Boasting six bedrooms and six bathrooms within 3,788 square feet of living space, this home exemplifies the fusion of rustic charm and modern luxury.
Original hardwood floors and a wood-burning fireplace lend warmth and character, while oversized windows offer stunning views of the surrounding nature. The property’s expansive grounds include nature trails and proximity to the Shu Nature Preserve, enhancing the home’s appeal for outdoor enthusiasts.
Mill Neck’s blend of privacy and accessibility—minutes from Locust Valley and Oyster Bay—makes it an ideal retreat for those seeking tranquility with proximity to amenities.
Listed by Christina G. Volz and John Canino of Berkshire Hathaway; bought with Marie T. Salerno of Douglas Elliman Real Estate
Meanwhile, in the heart of Port Washington, 21 Mackey Avenue offers a taste of historic charm. This Dutch Colonial, built by renowned local builder Henry Decker, sold for $895,000 on Jan. 10.
With 1,969 square feet, the home features three bedrooms and two bathrooms. Its traditional design, highlighted by intricate woodwork, exposed beams and pocket doors, creates a cozy, inviting atmosphere. The home also includes a private deck, garden and a detached garage on a generously sized 8,800-square-foot corner lot.
Its location, just blocks from Main Street and the LIRR, offers easy access to shopping, dining and public transportation. Despite its proximity to the vibrant heart of Port Washington, the property enjoys a sense of seclusion, making it a peaceful escape within the bustling community.
Listed by Karen J. Bruning and Daniel Gale Sothebys International Realty; bought with Darren R. Mansell of Papillon Homes Inc.
Compiled by Christy Hinko; details and photos courtesy of Zillow and OneKey MLS.