Cold Stone Creamery Sued: Woman Claims ‘Heartbreak’ After Finding Pistachio Ice Cream Isn’t Made with Nuts

In today’s edition of “petty grievances escalated to an absurd level,” a popular ice cream chain has been sued for allegedly misleading customers as to the ingredients of one of its most popular flavors.

In a case currently dividing opinions on the internet, a woman has sued Cold Stone Creamery because, allegedly, its pistachio ice cream contained no actual pistachios.

Really.

As reported in the U.K.’s Guardian, this whole sorry saga began in July 2022, when a Long Island woman ordered a scoop of pistachio ice cream at a local Cold Stone.

To her sorrow, however, upon looking up the ingredients later on, she found that it contained “pistachio flavoring” rather than actual pistachios.

Trending:

Judge Engoron Under Investigation for What Happened Before Slapping Trump with $454 Million Fine

The woman then decided this was enough grounds for a lawsuit, which has been escalated to the Eastern District Court of New York in Brooklyn, presided over by federal Judge Gary Brown.

According to Business Insider, the woman and her legal team argued that she “reasonably believed” that the offending dairy treat contained pistachios, and when she found it most likely did not, “heartbreak followed.”

Oh, boy.

In response to this heart-wrenching tragedy, the woman — or, more likely, her lawyer’s clerks — compiled a formidable amount of evidence, including comparisons with ice cream brands that actually contain pistachios, as well as a survey that found 85 percent of consumers believed that a pistachio-flavored product would contain pistachios.

Is this a frivolous lawsuit?

Judge Brown wrote that the case was a “deceptively complex question about the reasonable expectations,” and that, in response to Cold Stone’s argument, “It seems inconceivable that such a consumer should have to search online to find the relevant webpages while waiting in line to order a scoop of ice-cream.”

Granted, this woman might have a legitimate false advertising case.

After all, it would seem logical to assume that a pistachio-flavored product would contain actual pistachios.

However, the ingredient list did cite “natural flavor,” which has been the standard way for major food corporations to disguise their use of cheaper substitutes (though there could be at least a little pistachio in there).

As Healthline explained, the only requirement for “natural flavors” is that they be derived from a plant or animal.

Related:

Biden Admin Planning to Roll Out ID Cards for Illegal Immigrants This Summer: 10,000 Cards in First-Round Issue Across US

Still, all this legal hullabaloo has revolved around a cup of ice cream costing around $5.

False advertising aside, was this really worth this woman dedicating two years or more of her life, compiling evidence and lawyers and escalating this case to a federal court?

She easily could have gone back to the Cold Stone and asked for a refund, and that would have been the end of it.

This did not need to be taken before a federal judge.

But, in an increasingly entitled society, many genuinely believe that something as petty as a misleading ice cream name deserves legal and financial compensation.

And if the legal system allows them to escalate their petty grievance to a federal court, then, why should they think otherwise?


A Note from Our Deputy Managing Editor:

 

I heard a chilling comment the other day: “We don’t even know if an election will be held in 2024.” 

 

That wasn’t said by a conspiracy theorist or a doomsday prophet. No, former U.S. national security advisor Lt. Gen. Michael Flynn said that to the founder of The Western Journal, Floyd Brown.

 

Gen. Flynn’s warning means that the 2024 election is the most important election for every single living American. If we lose this one to the wealthy elites who hate us, hate God, and hate what America stands for, we can only assume that 248 years of American history and the values we hold dear to our hearts may soon vanish.

 

The end game is here, and as Benjamin Franklin said, “We must all hang together, or assuredly we shall all hang separately.”

 

All of this means that without you, it’s over. We have the platform, the journalists, and the experience to fight back hard, but Big Tech is strangling us through advertising blacklists, shadow bans, and algorithms. Did you know that we’ve been blacklisted by 90% of advertisers? Without direct support from you, our readers, we can’t continue the fight.

 

Can we count on your support? It may not seem like much, but a Western Journal Membership can make all the difference in the world because when you support us directly, you cut Big Tech out of the picture. They lose control. 

 

A monthly Western Journal Membership costs less than one coffee and breakfast sandwich each month, and it gets you access to ALL of our content — news, commentary, and premium articles. You’ll experience a radically reduced number of ads, and most importantly you will be vitally supporting the fight for America’s soul in 2024.

 

We are literally counting on you because without our members, The Western Journal would cease to exist. Will you join us in the fight? 

 

Sincerely,

Josh Manning

Deputy Managing Editor

The Western Journal

Source link